Josh Freeman

Draft Wrap Up

April 30, 2012 at 10:42am by Scott   •  9 Comments »

2012 Draft Roundip

With the Bucs having traded away their second-round pick in order to move back into the first to take Doug Martin, most people thought Mark Dominik would stand pat and wait for his third-rounder to hit. But Dominik is a sniper who sees what he wants and just fucking takes it. And what he wanted was LB Lavonte David out of Nebraska and he didn’t think think David was going to be there in the third for him. Someone in the chat on Friday called David as the next pick. I forget who it was, but bully for him. Nice call.

David is 6-0, 233 and runs a 4.65 40. Most people would call him undersized for a linebacker, but that would be his only drawback. He was super-productive at Nebraska and made all-conference after transferring from a junior college. He’s smart, athletic and closes on the football quick. It’s going to be tempting to compare him to Derrick Brooks because he’ll probably play the same position and because Brooks had the same “undersized” knock against him when he was drafted. This kid obviously has a long way to go, but just keep it in the back of your mind. This is why the Bucs felt comfortable passing on a linebacker in the first round. Dominik knew David was going to be there in the second and that freed him up to do what he did in the first.

I feel the need to point this out since there was so much Dominik bashing on Friday. Dominik traded down two spots to #7 and picked up a fourth-rounder, a price most people said was too low. Dominik took that fourth-rounder and used it to trade back up in the first to grab Martin. But all he did was swap fourths to do it. He still had a fourth-rounder going into the second. He then took that fourth to trade back into the second round for David. He used one fourth-rounder to trade up twice. That’s some expert wheeling and dealing, and if you don’t think so you’re just hater who enjoys being miserable and should pick another team to root for or bitch about as you please. But leave my Bucs out of your sphere of depression.

The rest of the draft I found underwhelming, mostly because I didn’t know any of the players. The Bucs took LB Najee Goode in the fifth and CB Keith Tandy, both from West Virginia. In fact, Goode and Tandy were roommates in college, so they should give the second-team back seven some continuity walking into camp. Greg Schiano played both these guys several times while at Rutgers (both WV and Rutgers are in the Big East), so he obviously spent some time scouting them even before he got to the Bucs.

“Obviously, I know a lot about both the West Virginia kids playing against them for four years,” former Rutgers coach Schiano said. “They were both a royal pain in the rear. As I told them, it’s good to be on the same side now.

“Those two guys are football maniacs. I mean, they love the game, and they play it with such passion.”

With his first seventh-round pick, Dominik grabbed Michael Smith, a running back from Utah State. Smith’s pick is all about speed and he is a true change-of-pace back. In fact, another team liked him so much that they offered Dominik a sixth-rounder next year for Smith right after he was drafted.

“I never had that happen before,” Dominik said.

Smith claimed to run a 4.26 at some point, but he was clocked at 4.32 at his pro day. That probably translates a few hundredths higher at the combine, but is still faster than anyone the Bucs currently have. Smith is 5-9, 207 and had a recent groin injury, so there’s going to be some talk about his size and durability, but for a seventh-rounder, he sounds like a steal. So I won’t hold it against Dominik for not drafting Tauren Poole out of Tennessee with this pick. Poole, by the way, went to Carolina on a UFA deal, so we’ll be seeing him soon enough.

The Bucs’ last pick was Drake Dunsmore, a tight end out of Northwestern who probably projects as a fullback. Erik Lorig and Luke Stocker already have the jobs of “white guys who can block” filled, so I’m going to say Dunsmore doesn’t make the team. Everyone else, though, I think has a real shot of sticking.

With nearly 48 hours passing since the draft ended, it seems like a good time to look at draft grades. Of course that’s dumb, but people do it anyway. SI gives the Bucs an A-, Ira Kaufman gives them a B+, Mel Kiper gave them something good (I’ll never know because I won’t pay for it, but the Bucs did well enough to be the team they push on the home page), and CBS gives them a solid B. All the draft reviews have the same complaint, though: that the Bucs should have just taken Morris Claiborne. But without the trade down, the trades back up don’t happen. Barron is a solid player at a position of huge need for the team. And again, if the Bucs thought Claiborne was better than Mark Barron, they would have taken him. But the Bucs were in a unique position to know a lot about Claiborne and they went ahead and picked Barron anyway. That’s the last time I’ll beat that horse, but it seems so obvious that I don’t know why more people aren’t realizing it.

9 Comments to “Draft Wrap Up”


campyone (April 30, 2012 at 11:04am:

I pay for it. On an overall basis he gave the Bucs an A, with an A+ for value and a B+ for needs. IOWs, he (and the other “experts”)think this was a great draft for the Bucs and so do I though I know nothing about any of the players after David.

Matt Price

Matt Price (April 30, 2012 at 01:14pm:

Scott, I will say right now that I am EXTREMELY happy! I feel like the team already has a solid new identity.

Baron was who the Bucs needed, not Claiborne because the Bucs had to stop the run and the short passes over the middle. Baron is that tough hitter with the range and speed to make the happen. So is David apparently. Those guys will make our defense credible again on day one.

Add in the great free agent pick ups and the fact Schiano just strikes me as one serious and capable dude, and I’m thrilled. I finally feel like this time has a future again — something I haven’t felt since Gruden’s first couple years.

Matt Price

Matt Price (April 30, 2012 at 01:16pm:

P.S. Scott, If you ever do speak with Dominik again…

Tell him that some of us at least think he’s doing a great job. He’s shown tremendous courage, vision and brains. Right now, I honestly wouldn’t trade him for any other GM.


jampersands (April 30, 2012 at 01:17pm:

Agree 100% with the last paragraph. Bucs knew everything about Claiborne. If they didn’t take him at 5, they didn’t want him.

And quite obviously the armchair GM’s (such as myself) should defer to his college position coach when assessing his skills in the pros.

Mark S

Mark S (April 30, 2012 at 02:02pm:

Everything good has been said, so I am just going to sit back and grin.


FireThemCannons (April 30, 2012 at 02:11pm:

once again…can’t even explain how happy I am to have David on the Bucs dude as a terror on the Blackshirt defense of Nebraska, I also like the signing of Yoshi Hardrick after the draft, kid was very solid in college at left tackle and could push to get named the backup at RT this year. Now, lets get McCoy and Price 100%, Lets have Clayborn build on his solid rookie season, and Bowers continue to progress…as Bart Scott once said… “Can’t Wait”


FireThemCannons (April 30, 2012 at 04:40pm:

Holy shit…I was so excited about David being on the picture I didn’t even click it….I’m glad I did now…10/10


Meatmaster (April 30, 2012 at 06:07pm:

Awesome draft. Better clicky. I’d like to use her dirty panties for a coffee filter.


BaldBuc4055 (May 01, 2012 at 01:38am:

The first three picks were so awesome, that if the rest of the guys we picked make any sort of contribution, it will be a nice bonus. If we were having a draft for clickies, the one that accompanies this post is definitely a Top 5 pick…..a guaranteed franchise cornerstone.

Comment on this post:

You must be logged in to post a comment.